 New link in the top of page "IRC Chat". |
| Register | Login | |||||
 |
Main
| Memberlist
| Active users
| Calendar
| Last Posts
| IRC Chat
| Online users Ranks | FAQ | XPW | Stats | Color Chart | Photo album |
|
| | ||
New link in the top of page "IRC Chat". |
| Register | Login | |||||
|
Main
| Memberlist
| Active users
| Calendar
| Last Posts
| IRC Chat
| Online users Ranks | FAQ | XPW | Stats | Color Chart | Photo album |
|
| | ||
| 0 users currently in Debate Shrine. |
| Xeogaming Forums - Debate Shrine - Was using the photos ethical? |
 |  | Thread closed |
| Next newer thread | Next older thread |
| User | Post | ||
|
Rogue If you're reading this... You are the Resistance         Since: 08-17-04 Since last post: 633 days Last activity: 442 days |
| ||
| A couple days ago, while working on the last page I'll have to do for the paper this semester, I heard tires screech followed by the definite sound of cars colliding.
I stood up really quickly, as my desk faces a window, and saw two smashed up cars and a girl laying, bloody in the street. She was standing at the crosswalk that all of us comm students use to get to and from main campus (the communications building is the only thing on our side of the street), and was thrown 20 feet down the street. None of us in the office knew it at the time, but the girl was one of our staff writers. Within a minute, we saw our news director running out onto the street, holding her and making sure she was all right. He's in the army, currently in the reserves. As soon as other bystanders came forward to help him, he took out his camera and started taking pictures for the paper. Most of the people in the office sighed and said taking pictures was invading her privacy. A couple of the pictures were printed on the next day's front page, and we've been getting comments from people saying the picture is inappropriate and unnecessary. I personally feel the pictures put a human face to the accident and inform people that the corner is rather dangerous. This was definitely not the first accident at that intersection this semester, and many students have voiced that the corner needs a "No Turn on Red" sign. Thoughts? (Last edited by Rogue on 05-15-09 08:13 PM) |
|||
Lord Vulkas Mormonus Vile High Xeodent of Xeomerica.  Since: 10-29-04 From: North Carolina, United States. World, Sol System, milky way Since last post: 94 days Last activity: 94 days |
| ||
| It really all depends on how she'd feel about it. If she has a problem with it, it was wrong. If she was fine with it, it was alright. So, really, he should have waited publishing it until she was able to give permission.
Also, don't people hold a copyright over their likeness? I read somewhere that someone can sue if their face is used without permission, although, givent he number of pictures newspapers and articles put up, there's probably some way to get around that. Either way though, I think he should have waited for her permission before publishing it. |
|||
Cteno Super Shotgun Moderator Since: 01-11-05 Since last post: 91 days Last activity: 89 days |
| ||
| I thought it was that whoever took the picture owns the copyright to it, making it so snuff magazines are able to get away with all of their slander. I could easily be wrong on this, though. | |||
|
Lord Vulkas Mormonus Vile High Xeodent of Xeomerica. Since: 10-29-04 From: North Carolina, United States. World, Sol System, milky way Since last post: 94 days Last activity: 94 days |
| ||
| http://www.citmedialaw.org/legal-guide/using-name-or-likeness-another
Okay, so it's just for publicity, or invasion of privacy. I was at least close to being right! |
|||
Katana Dark Wizard \"She said tonight...come on come on collide...see what I fire feels like..I bet its just like heaven.\"  Since: 08-15-04 From: Philadelphia, P.A. Since last post: 1554 days Last activity: 1371 days |
| ||
(I typed most of this up before Vulkar ninja posted me and kindly warned me about it.  But, I'm not changing it. Despite the link he provided for this specific issue, there is still a general idea about this sort of topic.)
This really isn't much of a black or white issue here. I think there's a bit of a gray area here. In the name of preventing something like that from happening again, and from adding more substance to the voices behind the calls for certain actions (The "no turn on red" sign), I do not think he was wrong to take the pictures and post them even. Whether or not he should have waited to get permission, because the girl and her family do have a right to object to it, is yet another gray area. Sometimes you don't have time to wait. Action needs to be taken and decisions need to be made in an instant. So, the action taken could have been a measure to, like Rogue already said, put a face to the incident, in order to get something done about it. It was okay, in my opinion, for him to act instantly. BUT, it's also okay for the family to see this and demand that there be no more pictures published, and maybe even an appology if they are truly devastated by the pictures. |
|||
Elara Divine Mamkute Dark Elf Goddess Chaos Imp Penguins Fan Ms. Invisable  Since: 08-15-04 From: Ferelden Since last post: 99 days Last activity: 99 days |
| ||
| People don't like seeing gruesome images, it bothers them, so of course they are going to bitch about it. I don't think he did anything wrong, and I agree with you Rogue that he put a human face on the accident. It is a lot harder for people to ignore a problem when it has a face. | |||
|
Sólrök Newcomer Since: 08-12-09 From: Mimimei∂r Since last post: 5577 days Last activity: 5574 days |
| ||
| The only reason this situation is questionable from a newspaper standard is that it hits too close to home, which can be a strike against credibility when its primary goal is to be unbiased. This is, of course, assuming nothing questionable was in the photos. If it was just of the wreck and not her, then there's nothing to be spoken about, as there was nothing ethical to be considered. If there was a picture of her bloodied, then yes, there would be an ethical issue but I'm assuming that's not the case.
If the piece was merely about the wreck itself as an informational piece, then it seems biased being that you don't give all wrecks the same relevance and importance. But if you gave it the slant and local angle of being relevant to the student body and their well-being at that particular corner, and the dangers that are there, then its the perfect local-college news piece. Anyway, that's my perspective. I've worked in a local news paper for the past three years, under many different titles. Any editor with a head would understand the above concepts, so I doubt you pushed the line in any way, and you should try and have confidence in that. Some people, many people in fact, are over sensitive. |
|||
Topos Goomba Banned for flaming and flamebaiting Since: 08-28-10 Since last post: 5198 days Last activity: 5199 days |
| ||
Originally posted by Elara Unless darkies are involved apparently! |
|||
|
Elara Divine Mamkute Dark Elf Goddess Chaos Imp Penguins Fan Ms. Invisable Since: 08-15-04 From: Ferelden Since last post: 99 days Last activity: 99 days |
| ||
| You're trying to flame-bait... cute... bye now. |
| Next newer thread | Next older thread |
| Xeogaming Forums - Debate Shrine - Was using the photos ethical? |
| Thread closed |
